NCA Sample Practice Question

 

Sample NCA Torts Question

About This Sample Question

This sample features a condensed fact pattern and narrower question scope than the questions contained in Brickam’s full NCA practice exams. It is designed to demonstrate the style, level of difficulty and depth of legal analysis used in our materials. Full practice-exam questions contain longer factual scenarios, greater issue density and broader examination scope.

Instructions Specific to This Exam

  1. This sample contains one question worth 15 marks.
  2. You will be assessed primarily on your knowledge of the relevant Canadian tort-law principles and authorities, together with your ability to identify the legal issues raised by the facts, apply the governing law and assess competing arguments.
  3. No marks are awarded for merely reproducing or summarizing the facts. Use the facts in your legal analysis.
  4. Answer the question actually asked. Do not discuss causes of action or issues that have been expressly excluded.
  5. Full case citations are unnecessary. The name of the relevant authority is sufficient.
  6. Where the facts reasonably support competing conclusions, address the strongest arguments available to both sides before reaching a reasoned conclusion.
  7. Write a clear and organized answer in complete sentences.

 

QUESTION

FACTS

Mireille Daoust is a 38-year-old air-ambulance helicopter pilot.

For several years, Mireille has experienced recurring corneal erosions in her right eye. The episodes are painful and occasionally prevent her from working for one or two days, but they have not affected her visual acuity between episodes.

Her ophthalmologist, Dr. Elias Norwood, recommends an elective surgical procedure intended to reduce the likelihood of future erosions.

The procedure has approximately a 90% likelihood of materially improving Mireille’s condition.

There is also an approximately 2% risk that the procedure will cause persistent glare and halos around lights at night. For most patients, those symptoms would be inconvenient but would not substantially interfere with ordinary daily activities.

For Mireille, however, persistent night-vision impairment could prevent her from satisfying the medical requirements necessary to continue flying air-ambulance operations at night.

A non-surgical alternative is also available. Mireille could continue using prescription eye drops and a protective contact lens for another six months. That treatment has approximately a 60% likelihood of controlling her symptoms and does not carry the same risk of permanent night-vision impairment.

The surgery is not urgent.

During her consultation, Mireille tells Dr. Norwood:

“I can live with the occasional pain for now. What I absolutely cannot afford is anything that permanently affects my night vision. Flying at night is a huge part of my job.”

Dr. Norwood explains:

  • how the surgery will be performed;
  • the expected recovery period;
  • the possibility of infection; and
  • the possibility that the procedure may not eliminate Mireille’s symptoms.

He does not tell her about:

  • the 2% risk of persistent glare and halos; or
  • the option of continuing non-surgical treatment.

Dr. Norwood later explains:

“The risk was very small and the surgery works for the large majority of patients. I did not think the 2% figure should discourage her from an effective procedure.”

Mireille agrees to the surgery.

The procedure itself is performed competently.

Unfortunately, the known 2% complication occurs. Mireille develops persistent glare and halos while flying at night and subsequently loses the medical clearance necessary to perform night operations.

Mireille says:

“If he had told me there was even a small chance of permanently affecting my night vision, I would have tried the non-surgical treatment first.”

Dr. Norwood responds:

“Most reasonable patients would still choose a treatment with a 90% success rate rather than spend another six months on something that only has a 60% chance of working.”

QUESTION

Advise Mireille concerning a potential negligence claim against Dr. Norwood arising from the information provided before she agreed to the procedure.

Address the significant legal issues, the strongest arguments available to both parties and the likely outcome.

Do not address:

  • whether the surgery itself was performed negligently;
  • statutory health-care consent legislation; or
  • the assessment of damages.

15 MARKS

 

 

THE BRICKAM EXPLANATION

The Claim Is Properly Analyzed in Negligence

Mireille agreed to the procedure Dr. Norwood actually performed.

Her complaint is therefore not that:

  • she never consented to surgery; or
  • Dr. Norwood performed a materially different procedure from the one she authorized.

Instead, she argues that she agreed to the procedure without receiving information necessary to make an informed treatment decision.

Under Reibl v. Hughes, where a patient consents to the nature of the procedure actually performed, an allegation that the physician failed to disclose material risks is ordinarily analyzed in negligence rather than battery.

The central questions are therefore:

  1. whether Dr. Norwood failed to disclose information that ought reasonably to have been disclosed; and
  2. whether adequate disclosure would probably have changed Mireille’s treatment decision.

The Physician Must Disclose Material Risks

A physician must disclose material risks associated with proposed treatment.

Whether a risk is material is not determined solely by its statistical probability.

The analysis also considers matters such as:

  • the seriousness of the possible consequences;
  • the nature and urgency of the procedure;
  • available alternatives; and
  • circumstances particular to the patient that are known to the physician.

A relatively unlikely risk can therefore be material where its consequences would be unusually serious for the particular patient.

The 2% Risk Was Likely Material to Mireille

Dr. Norwood’s strongest argument is that the complication occurs in only approximately 2% of patients.

For many patients, persistent glare and halos may amount primarily to inconvenience.

Mireille’s circumstances are materially different.

The complication threatens her ability to:

  • satisfy occupational medical requirements; and
  • continue a significant part of her career.

More importantly, Mireille expressly told Dr. Norwood:

“What I absolutely cannot afford is anything that permanently affects my night vision.”

Dr. Norwood therefore knew that this particular risk carried unusually serious consequences for her.

The issue is not simply whether 2% is a high probability.

The proper question is whether a reasonable person in Mireille’s circumstances would consider the risk significant when deciding whether to undergo surgery.

On these facts, the risk was likely material and should have been disclosed.

Mireille’s Express Concern Strengthens the Duty to Disclose

Mireille did not merely possess an unusual occupational concern that Dr. Norwood could not reasonably have known.

She communicated it directly.

That significantly weakens his argument that the risk was too statistically small to warrant discussion.

Dr. Norwood’s personal view that disclosure might discourage Mireille from choosing what he considered the more effective procedure does not determine materiality.

The purpose of disclosure is to enable the patient to make an informed choice between available treatment options.

The Non-Surgical Alternative Was Also Significant

The surgery was elective.

Mireille had the option of continuing conservative treatment for another six months.

That alternative:

  • had a lower likelihood of success;
  • might leave her experiencing symptoms for longer;
  • but avoided the particular surgical risk that threatened her occupation.

This was therefore not a choice between:

surgery or no meaningful treatment.

Mireille had a genuine alternative involving a different balance of risks and benefits.

Information concerning that alternative was relevant to her treatment decision and strengthens the argument that Dr. Norwood’s disclosure was inadequate.

Causation Must Be Established Separately

Even if Dr. Norwood breached his disclosure obligation, Mireille must establish that the failure caused her loss.

Her present statement:

“I would have tried the non-surgical treatment first”

is relevant, but it is not automatically decisive.

If the test were entirely subjective, a patient who suffered an undisclosed complication could almost always testify afterward that they would have refused the treatment.

Canadian law therefore does not determine causation solely from the patient’s hindsight evidence.

Reibl Applies a Modified Objective Approach

Under the approach in Reibl v. Hughes, the court considers what a reasonable person in the patient’s position, properly informed, would probably have decided.

This permits the court to take account of circumstances genuinely particular to Mireille while avoiding a purely subjective hindsight test.

Dr. Norwood therefore has a meaningful causation argument.

The surgery offered approximately:

  • a 90% likelihood of improvement,

while conservative treatment offered approximately:

  • a 60% likelihood of controlling the condition.

A reasonable patient could regard that difference as significant enough to accept a small surgical risk.

Mireille Nevertheless Has Strong Causation Facts

Several facts support Mireille.

First, the surgery was not urgent. There was time to attempt another treatment.

Second, the alternative did not expose her to the same risk of permanent night-vision impairment.

Third, Mireille had already indicated that she could tolerate the existing symptoms temporarily.

Most importantly, permanent night-vision impairment could threaten her livelihood, and preservation of night vision was a concern she expressly identified before the procedure.

A reasonable air-ambulance pilot in Mireille’s position could therefore rationally decide:

“I will first try the less successful treatment because it does not put my career at risk. If that fails, I can reconsider surgery later.”

That considerably strengthens causation.

Mireille Did Not Need to Establish That She Would Never Have Had Surgery

Mireille’s case does not necessarily depend upon proving that she would have refused surgery permanently.

Her position is that she would not have undergone the procedure when she did.

She says she would first have attempted conservative treatment.

If proper disclosure would probably have caused her to postpone the surgery and pursue the available alternative, the fact that she might later have reconsidered surgery does not automatically defeat causation.

The court must determine what probably would have happened had she been adequately informed at the relevant time.

Likely Outcome

Mireille has a strong negligence claim.

Dr. Norwood likely failed to disclose information material to her treatment decision, particularly:

  • the risk of persistent night-vision impairment; and
  • the available non-surgical alternative.

The relatively low 2% probability does not make the risk immaterial because its potential consequence was unusually serious for Mireille and Dr. Norwood specifically knew why.

Causation is the more contestable element.

Dr. Norwood can legitimately rely on the surgery’s substantially higher likelihood of success.

Nevertheless, the combination of:

  • Mireille’s expressly communicated occupational concern;
  • the elective nature of the surgery;
  • the absence of urgency;
  • her willingness to tolerate the condition temporarily; and
  • the availability of a lower-risk alternative

provides a strong basis for concluding that a reasonable person in Mireille’s position would have attempted conservative treatment before undergoing surgery.

 

Brickam’s Suggested Marking Approach

Issue Marks
Correctly characterizes the inadequate-disclosure claim as negligence and identifies the Reibl framework 2
Explains the obligation to disclose material risks and relevant treatment alternatives 2
Applies materiality to the 2% risk, seriousness of the consequence and Mireille’s expressly communicated occupational circumstances 3
Analyzes the significance of the non-surgical alternative and elective nature of the procedure 2
Identifies causation as a separate requirement and rejects a purely subjective hindsight approach 2
Applies the modified objective approach and analyzes the competing 90% versus 60% treatment considerations 3
Reaches a reasoned overall conclusion 1
TOTAL 15